Homework Meltdown

1animated10-thumb2Little Eva is only six and in first grade, yet she has to do homework every night. Five nights a week, she has a math worksheet to do. Seven nights a week, she is required to read two little “easy reader” books. Since she was an infant, we have read a story or two to her every night at bedtime. Every night. This summer, Eva was happily reading easy reader books aloud to us as well. Now that she has to read them every day, it has become a chore and the joy of reading is already fading. Honestly, it’s killing me. My Masters in Education training and research taught me that children are better off learning to read at seven or eight. Furthermore, there is ample research on how children love to read until they are forced to do it for homework. School homework really can kill a lust for reading. I just never thought it would happen so soon. My friends who are the parents of second graders in the district warn me that the second graders are not only required to read every night, but they are required to write about it every night as well. This is just too soon.

When Eva gets home from a full day of school with a mere twenty minutes of recess and gym class only once every three days, she is very tired (don’t even get me started, my letter to the Superintendent about the need for more free play and recess has gone unanswered for over a month now). I’d much rather she have the choice to read aloud to us. However, if she takes a night off, she won’t get a cute stamp on her calendar for that day. If she doesn’t do her math homework, she misses out on the few minutes of “play time” which is really snack time. Incidentally, I don’t have her over-scheduled. On the weekdays, she has ballet one day a week and martial arts one day a week. On the weekends, she goes to Sunday school every week and Brownies once a month for an hour.

The other night, poor Eva was tired and didn’t want to do her math homework. She wanted me to give her the answers. When I refused, she flipped out. I had never seen her like this. She was knocking things off her desk, toppling furniture, kicking and screaming. She threw the worksheet at me and yelled, “Just rip it up Mom! Rip it up!” When I wouldn’t she grabbed it back and took a marker and blacked out all the answers she had done so far. This just broke my heart. She is way too young for this.

I am simply at a loss as to how I can change the homework policy at this school. They are so driven to get their scores up. They have made Kindergarten into first grade and first grade into third grade. My daughter is doing homework here in Skokie that my friends’ third graders are doing in Northbrook (schools with much higher scores I might add). Can I make a difference in this district that has been determined to excel at all costs? Would these administrators be willing to turn back the policies they just put into place in the last two years? I’d like to try.

Advertisements

3 Responses to “Homework Meltdown”

  1. sdscaiff Says:

    Arrgghh! When will educators realise that kids and adults who study for the pleasure of learning do better (even on standardized tests) than those who study to do better on tests, especially standardized tests!!! It is a waste of time to push to get scores up. Far better to engage kids in learning and let them rest and play at home when they are young.
    We all need lunch breaks, rest, recreation and exercise during the day to be effective; the fact that most adults don’t take these breaks does not mean it is healthy, it just means that they are poor role models.
    Many grade ones are almost too tired to eat supper after a day at school, much less do homework. The school board should look around at other countries; many refuse to give homework to children under the age of 11. The children are still successful learners.

  2. Felicia Says:

    It is so sad. I taught preschool/Kindergarten for 10 yrs and saw the curriculum change and they lost so much of that open ended play. Their little spirits just got crushed. No more alphabets in shaving cream. It was just sad. Now that I am a mom I shudder at the thought of the pressure she is going to be under in a few years. The idea of homeschooling looks better and better.

    I hope your plea to the administrators get answered. I know what I protested the curriculum in our school I was basically told I could find employment elsewhere.

  3. moodymommy Says:

    Felicia & Sdscaiff, Thanks for your comments. So far, I haven’t found any parents who are in favor of more homework and less free play for the kids. Who is driving these changes if not the parents?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: